If I had to choose the worst book world to live in, I would choose The Hunger Games.
There are fictional places I would happily visit. Show me an enchanted library, and I’ll pack a bag. Mention a cottage with an unreasonable number of books, and I may already be forwarding my mail.
But Panem?
I have reviewed the situation, and I would like to decline.
For starters, I do not want to live under a government that considers televised murder an appropriate annual event. That is a considerable problem with the neighborhood, and I doubt a strongly worded letter would resolve it.
Then there is the possibility of being sent into an arena where survival depends on speed, wilderness skills, and the ability to recognize which berries are trying to kill you.
I know things about myself.
I would ask whether there was somewhere to sit before we had made it through the introductory instructions.
Someone would hand me a weapon, and I would wonder whether we had fully explored the possibility of a conversation. Someone else would explain that the conversation needed to happen while running.
Our working relationship would deteriorate.
And I would be entirely too interested in everyone’s story.
The person I am apparently supposed to view as competition? I would want to know whether they had eaten. Whether someone was waiting for them at home. Whether they were frightened and doing a very good job of hiding it.
This would make me inconvenient to the people organizing the spectacle.
Good.
That is what makes this world so awful to imagine living in. The cruelty is organized. People with power have made suffering into entertainment, and everyone else is expected to accept the arrangement.
Even being safely outside the arena would mean living with that knowledge. Comfort would be difficult to enjoy while knowing what it cost someone else.
I like to imagine I would be brave. Most of us probably do when the danger stays politely between the covers of a book.
But I suspect my courage would arrive with a trembling voice and several requests for clarification. I would still hope to help someone. Perhaps I could offer food, keep a confidence, or simply refuse to let the spectacle make me forget that these were people.
Then I would very much like to return to a world where my greatest evening conflict is deciding which book to open.
So keep your invitation to Panem. I will be on the porch with a cup of coffee and a novel I can close whenever things become unreasonable.
I enjoy a gripping story. I do not wish to become a cautionary subplot.
